Something about stay-at-home motherhood feels terribly
indulgent, (much like this venti pumpkin spice latte I’m enjoying in Starbucks
right now) even though it’s terribly hard work.
Yes, I’m currently sitting in Starbucks, typing away at my computer,
pretending mightily that I’m a very important person, writing the next great
American novel, or the solution to the middle East conflicts, maybe. Why is mommy-blogging not enough?
Part of it is very simple.
I just need a break every now and again.
When my oldest daughter was a baby I felt very, very guilty for even wanting a break. I thought it meant I
didn’t love her enough. I always thought
about the moms I knew (or thought I knew) that didn’t seem to need breaks. They took so much frickin joy in their kids
they made me sick with guilt. I’m going
to admit something now that I’m not actually sure is a great idea on a public
blog. Something I’m terribly ashamed of.
I don’t actually like playing
with my kids that much. I find it, well,
boring.
Wow. That was
hard. Now don’t get me wrong. I love my kids more than life itself. I’ve never loved anyone or anything like I
love my kids. It’s an unimaginable
love. Did I mention I really, really
love my kids? (Or, super love them, as my almost-four-year-old would say). But when I take a block and give it back to
my one-year-old over and over and over again sometimes I count the minutes till
bedtime. And pretending to be a princess
kinda makes me want to die. Ok, that’s a
bit of dramatic hyperbole. But playing
with kids is hard, hard work. It’s not
cognitively engaging, it’s repetitive, it’s not productive, at least not in the
sense that I have a pile of something I made or folded at the end of it. But I do it, maybe not quite as much as I
should, maybe I sneak glances at my phone now and again, but there I am,
handing blocks to my baby and twirling with my four-year-old. Who wouldn’t need a break from that? I yearn to be more productive, to contribute
to society in some way. People say my
contribution to society is that I’m raising great kids. But what if all they do is raise great
kids? Then I’ve just contributed to
over-population.
So the above admission might seem a little strange to people
who know me. I’m a teacher for goodness
sake, and I think a lot about education.
But somehow, when it’s not my kids, play is more interesting. I analyze it.
I look at development. I find it
cognitively engaging. I think I’m a bit
afraid to do that with my kids. I’m
afraid I might find some developmental deficiency. (Cue my mother, rolling her eyes). Or maybe I
just already know them so well that their play isn’t all that revealing on a
day to day basis. Whatever it is, I find
myself having to force myself to play with my kids. Luckily, I’m more successful at forcing
myself to play with my kids than I am say, at forcing myself to clean the
bathroom. But I think I’m getting
better. Maybe I just find my
four-year-old more engaging recently. I
like teaching her things. I like, as her
preschool teacher puts it, “doping her play.” I’ve been saving the tops of baby food pouches
(thank you, pinterest), and today I poured them all out on the table and
started sorting them by color. My
four-year-old, predictably, stopped what she was doing, and came over to me.
“Whatcha doin’, Mom?”
“Oh, just sorting these baby food tops. I want to know if there are more purple or
more green tops.”
“I want to do that!” she said as she practically pushed me
out of the chair. That’s play
doping. And man, it’s fun. I’m sure there’s some psychological reason
for that, but I think it’s disturbing, so I’ll let that one go.
And I hope that play-doping is enough contribution to
society. I hope I can somehow dope compassion and intelligence and ambition
into play. If anyone has any idea how to
do that, please let me know.
But I still need a break sometimes. I need to sit in a café and pretend I’m an
adult, after pretending to be a princess all day long. I’m deciding right now, I’m going to forgive
myself for that. Time will tell if my
kids will forgive me. For now I’ll just
put a dollar in the therapy jar.
Guess what? I bet you'll get WAY more moms agreeing with you than not. We've finally agreed in this house that games where the 3-year old says "you be the Mommy and I'll be the little girl" ARE NOT HAPPENING. Because Mommy just. . .can't . . .
ReplyDeleteI do wonder about contributing to society. We (at-home moms) do invisible work. And we live in a society where our work is treated as value-less. Maternity leave? 6 weeks, paid if you're lucky. Funds for childcare, education, care of impoverished families. . . Just take a look at our state budget & the upcoming elections to see where we stand on that!
What if we lived in a country where we got 2 years paid maternity leave & Dad got a year? Would you feel that same concern? If motherhood (parenthood, parenting, families) were treated as the reason for society instead of an encumberance? Why isn't this the most valuable contribution we could make?
Cheri, you raise superb questions about how society values motherhood. I'd love to talk to some stay at home moms in the countries that do offer the benefits you describe and ask them how satisfied they are with their societal contributions.
ReplyDeleteI'm making a documentary about this. Or at least partly about this. About women and motherhood and contributing to society. Enjoyed this post a lot.
ReplyDelete